Movies 1 & 2 (Sorceror’s Stone & Chamber of Secrets) were almost exactly as the books read. Movie 3, Prisoner of Azkaban, was ok, but missing some things that are very important (like this one, what’s the deal with Sirius-centric stories missing key details??). Movie 4 (Goblet of Fire), although missing some extra details, stuck to the story and its pace and its path pretty well, while including some fun extra things to keep you more than interested.
This movie, Order of the Phoenix, however, kept the storyline, but took liberties with the path of the story, putting things from the end in the middle, and the middle in the end, and leaving some important things out altogether.
To those of you who have seen the movie and read the book, you will know what I mean when I say that the movie was great in its own right, but truly missing some very important information.
To anyone who has NOT seen the movie, I really recommend you do because it is a great movie in and of itself. You should read the items below so you have a better idea of the bigger picture, however, but ONLY if you don’t plan on reading the book (spoilers for the book, but NEEDED info for the movie if you won’t read the book)!
Here, some info that may help the movie flow along much better and the story make a little more sense:
******************************
******************************
*****BOOK*5*SPOILER*ALERT
******************************
*****BOOK*5*SPOILER*ALERT
******************************
*****BOOK*5*SPOILER*ALERT
******************************
******************************
1. Ron and Hermione become Prefects in Harry Potter & the Order of the Phoenix. (Yes, I said Ron!
) Prefects are the students who watch over the other kids in Gryfindor. Harry, however, is NOT selected as a prefect despite his past doings, and this contributes to his feeling more and more separated from his very best of friends and Dumbledore.
2. Rita Skeeter, an annoying reporter, works for The Daily Prophet and plays an important part in the book, pestering Harry, wanting to know everything, and publishing the “Truth about Harry & Voldemort”.
2b. The Quibbler, the magazine you’ll see Luna Lovegood holding, is banned by Dolores Umbridge. Luna father is the editor.
3. Hermione, in this book, starts a Society for the Protection of House Elves (SPEW) and insists that all be nice to Kreacher, Sirius’s house elf. Kreacher may not deserve the fair treatment Hermione insists he get after all.
4. The prophecy in the movie is revealed to all, but in the book, Harry still keeps the full prophecy a secret from Ron & Hermione through the end.
5. There is an important character, a possible hero, in the major student characters who nobody would expect, hinted at in the book, but not the movie.
6. A budding friendship between Harry and another female character is completely left out of the movie, but is in the book.
7. In the 5th book, a centaur becomes their teacher of a particular subject, but this Centaur, who plays an important character in the book, isn’t even mentioned by name in the movie.
8. The original prophecy was made by a very particular character showing this character’s true importance and why Dumbledore cares even slightly for the character as he does in the movie, but this explanation is also left out of the movie.
9. Bellatrix Lestrange is Sirius Black’s cousin, and also related to the Malfoys through marriage.
10. Slytherin gets some new Quidditch players (if you’re going to see this movie for Quidditch alone, that aspect is left out).
11. Percy Weasley is an employee of the Ministry of Magic and because of this, is not really speaking with his family. (In the movie, in the Minsitry, you will see a lanky curly red haired young man. That is Percy. I don’t recall that they actually address him by name at any point in the movie.)
12. Cho Chang and Verita Serum are much more explained in the book.
13. Dumbledore has a VERY good reason for separating himself from Harry, explained in detail in the book, but not so much in the movie.
******************************
******************************
*****END*OF*SPOILER*ALERT
******************************
*****END*OF*SPOILER*ALERT
******************************
*****END*OF*SPOILER*ALERT
******************************
******************************
Thanks for reading! I hope this is helpful for you when seeing the movie. They honestly could have included most of this, even briefly, and added only 30 minutes to the movie — A movie I KNOW people would have still seen had it been 2 hrs 48 minutes rather than 2 hrs 18 minutes (Although I enjoyed the movie, I promise I did, I’m so disappointed in that aspect!)
FYI, Book 5 an 868 page book, while Books 1-3 were ~400 pages, and book 4 is ~650 pages. No reason whatsoever this should have been the shortest movie!!!